Concerned Singaporean sparks discussion about visible begging in public spaces.
SINGAPORE: A recent post on an online forum has sparked debate about a perceived increase in begging within Singapore’s shopping malls. The conversation began after a concerned individual recounted seeing a man soliciting money at Northpoint City Mall.
“Has anyone noticed a rise in begging happening inside Singapore’s shopping malls?” the user asked. “I was at Northpoint City Mall yesterday and saw someone sitting on the floor, crying out to passersby and asking for money with his hands outstretched.”
The poster described the individual as a Chinese male in his 50s, without any apparent physical impairments.
This observation resonated with other forum participants, who shared their own encounters.
“I saw a middle-aged, bald Chinese man at Clementi Mall near the escalator to the MRT, frequently targeting older individuals for money.”
“I’ve noticed a woman leading a ‘blind’ uncle selling tissue paper at a coffee shop. They made S$50 in about 10 minutes—more than what I earn,” another commented.
Mixed Reactions and Advice
Opinions in the thread varied widely. While some expressed empathy, others cautioned against impulsive giving.
One commenter emphasized the need for caution, suggesting that some individuals posing as beggars might not be genuinely in need. “Many of these ‘beggars’ are opportunists. The poorest here in Singapore do not have to beg for meals, as there are social services available. Longer-term, sustainable help is what they truly need.”
Another recommended reporting such instances to the authorities. “If you see someone begging in a mall, you can notify security to handle the situation or call the ComCare hotline.”
A few participants also encouraged helping through official channels. “If you truly want to assist the less fortunate, donate through proper charities. Giving money directly to individuals on the street doesn’t solve their underlying issues.”
Broader Context
Singapore has social safety nets like ComCare to provide assistance to those in financial distress. However, visible instances of begging can prompt questions about gaps in the system or the misuse of public spaces.
This discussion highlights a recurring concern: the balance between showing compassion and addressing the root causes of poverty in a society that prides itself on robust social welfare mechanisms.
