Public Reactions to Minister’s Statement Highlight Divided Opinions on Prison Conditions
Minister for Law and Home Affairs K Shanmugam’s remarks regarding the absence of mattresses in Singapore prisons have sparked mixed reactions among the public. He emphasized that such measures are in place due to hygiene and security concerns.
Many individuals expressed the sentiment that imprisonment should not resemble a holiday, arguing that inmates should not receive luxurious treatment. Conversely, others raised concerns about the lack of humanity shown to prisoners, suggesting it could hinder their rehabilitation and reintegration into society.
During a parliamentary session on Monday (July 4), Mr. Shanmugam explained that prison cells do not include fans or mattresses to minimize risks such as contraband smuggling and potential suicide. His comments followed a Channel News Asia documentary, “Inside Maximum Security,” which brought attention to the living conditions within Singapore’s correctional facilities.
Member of Parliament Murali Pillai (PAP – Bukit Batok) questioned whether current prison conditions align with Singapore Prison Service’s reputation as a leading correctional agency. Other MPs also sought information about the support available for inmates dealing with mental health issues or medical conditions.
Mr. Shanmugam pointed out that Singapore’s hot and humid climate makes the use of mattresses impractical. He added that fans cannot be mounted on cell walls due to the risk of them being dismantled and misused as weapons or potential suicide aids. Instead, he noted that inmates are provided with straw mats and that natural and mechanical ventilation is utilized within the prison compound. For those requiring additional care, specialized beds are available in medical wards and correctional units.
“Our assessment is that the conditions are acceptable and align with our philosophy of how prisons should operate,” stated Mr. Shanmugam, reiterating that inmates’ “essential needs” are met. He also mentioned that all prisoners undergo evaluations of their physical and mental health upon entry.
Reactions on social media have been varied. Facebook user Kathleen Kwan remarked, “If you committed a crime, you should be punished. That should include physical discomfort. Is discomfort inhumane? No.”
David Chang added, “A prison term is not a holiday resort. If they are so fond of luxurious treatment, then don’t break the law. Period.”
Conversely, some voices emphasized the importance of compassion in correctional settings. Stefan Ansorge questioned, “If you don’t show humanity and the chance for redemption towards prisoners, how do you expect them to become better people once they get out?”
